The Chair of
the Law Commission has a pivotal role both within the Commission and
externally. The
Chair, working with the Chief Executive, plays a key part in identifying and
responding to the strategic challenges that face the Commission. The Chair is also the public face of the Commission
and can expect to be asked by the media to give interviews. He or she represents the Commission in public
and is very much involved in meeting Ministers across Departments in order to
gain acceptance of Law Commission proposals.
The Chair will
also play a role in discussing budget and other strategic issues with Ministers
and senior officials in the Ministry of Justice. The Chair will lead on
relations with Parliament, particularly the Justice Committee, before whom the
Chair may be asked to give formal evidence from time to time.
The Chair also
leads, in conjunction with the relevant Commissioners, in relations concerning
Welsh law. The Commission considers it
to be of great importance that it always has projects in relation to devolved
Welsh law, ongoing at any one time. It
cannot perform its role as the Law Commission for Wales if this is not the
case. The Commission has a seat on the Executive
Committee of the recently formed Welsh Law Council, Chaired by Lord Lloyd
Jones. The Chair of the Law Commission sits as the representative of the
Commission
The Chair can expect to be involved to
some extent in all the projects being undertaken by the Commission, providing
guidance to other Commissioners and supporting legal teams. The Chair will also lead in seeking to find a
consensus where there are differing views about the best way to reform the
law. The Chair presides over the peer
review process, whereby the Commissioners collectively agree on lines of law
reform. The process is rigorous and
challenging but invariably leads to a material improvement in the finished
product.
Reports
published by the Commission are considered in detail, and signed, by all five
Commissioners. This may sometimes include supporting the completion of work
initiated by previous Commissioners. Because of the time that it can take to
reach the implementation of some of the Commission’s recommendations, the
Commissioners may find themselves involved in carrying forward the work of a
project in which none previously participated. Commissioners (including the
Chair) therefore need excellent team-working skills and a commitment to acting
corporately.
The Chair will
work closely with staff, but will not have line management responsibility. The
Chair plays a key leadership role and will be expected to work with the CEO to
ensure that the relationship between Commissioners and staff is a positive one.
The Commission
meet regularly; usually at least once a week to discuss the issues of the day. The
Board of the Law Commission meets monthly and the Chair leads discussions,
supported by the CEO.
The Chair is
answerable to the Lord Chancellor for the performance of his or her
functions. In addition to meetings with
the Lord Chancellor and other Ministers, the Chair has an annual discussion
with a senior official in the Ministry of Justice about the performance of the
Law Commission.
In a letter to
all Judges sent in 2021, which explained that a competition for the appointment
of a new Chair, would in due course commence, the present Chair described the
role in the following terms:
- The role of the Chair has evolved in recent years. In my experience, the role has been about
50/50 “law” and strategy.
- As for the legal side of the role, every document that emanates from the
Law Commission is signed off by the Chair and each of the other four
Commissioners. Collective responsibility
is central to our modus operandi. The job involves working with Commissioners
and their teams on individual projects to identify problems and find solutions,
acting as devil’s advocate, working with Parliamentary Counsel on drafting
issues or issues relating to Parliamentary procedure, and chairing
Commissioners Peer Review meetings. The Chair contributes to the full range of
legal issues that arise. These issues
are by their nature novel and difficult. Pragmatism, compromise and the ability
to come up with practical solutions are essential aspects of this side of the
role.
- The strategic part of the job involves acting as the outward face of the
Commission. This involves: advocating
for the independent Commission and its work; attending meetings with Ministers,
parliamentarians and senior civil servants; giving evidence to Parliamentary
committees or committees of the Senedd in Wales; leading or assisting in
negotiations over possible new reform projects; developing working
relationships across the City, with Universities and with broader society;
leading and developing relations between the Commission and the judiciary;
giving lectures about the work of the Commission; leading the dialogue with Law Commissions and
Governments abroad; dealing with the press and media; and, dealing with
politically sensitive issues as and when they arise. The Chair is also a leader
within the Commission, chairing meetings of Commissioners and the Board,
working closely with the CEO and taking a close interest in staff welfare,
corporate governance, diversity and future ways of working.”
The Law Commission was established in
1965 and is an independent arm’s length body operating under the sponsorship of
the Ministry of Justice. Our statutory function is to keep the law of England
and Wales under review and to recommend reform where it is needed. The aim of
the Commission is to ensure that the law is fair, modern, simple, and cost
effective. We achieve this by conducting law reform projects looking at areas
of law that are causing problems to individuals, businesses, the third sector
or Government. We examine the law, consider options for reform in consultation
with stakeholders, and finally make recommendations to Government and
Parliament.
We have produced more than 350 sets of
law reform recommendations over more than 50 years. Less than 10% of our
reports have been rejected in that time. More recently, only 3 reports have
been rejected in the last 15 years. We tackle any area of law that is suitable
for consideration by an independent body of legal policy experts. Our work
ranges from the highly technical, such as the repeal of obsolete enactments and
the streamlining of over-complicated law, to formulation of new legal
approaches to high-profile social and economic policy issues. Our projects
generally address relatively broad and complex areas of law rather than narrow
legal issues.
We employ, and work with, some of the
best legal minds in the country and have an excellent track record of building
consensus so that Government and Parliament can have confidence that our recommendations
can be implemented effectively.
The archetypal Law Commission
end-products are our detailed law reform reports. Our reports are often
accompanied by draft legislation and are backed up by impact assessments. We
also have experience in providing advice to Government, and in proposing draft
regulation or non-legislative solutions including official guidance and
explanatory legal clarification, often for a non-legal audience.
The Law Commission is not suitable for
projects where the answer is required in weeks. Our commitment to thorough
research and analysis, in-depth consultation and the Law Commissioners’
detailed peer review of our law reform teams’ work, means that our projects are
likely to take in excess of twelve months.
The Commission has five statutory
Commissioners. The Chair is a serving Court of Appeal Judge. Each of the other
four Commissioners is a leading legal expert and oversees a team of lawyers and
research assistants working in one of four teams, currently: Criminal Law;
Property, Family and Trust Law; Public Law and Welsh Law; and, Commercial and
Common Law.
A full list of current Law Commission
projects is available on our website (www.lawcom.gov.uk).
Consultation
The Commission is asked to consider some
of the most challenging areas of the law. We have the capacity to work through
the issues and understand the differing perspectives before we put forward
recommendations for reform. The Commission is wedded to the principles of
genuine public consultation with the widest possible audience. This enables
thorough scrutiny of our proposals, which will often be developed or adjusted
in light of the contributions of stakeholders, both in the UK and overseas.
Our approach invariably involves a
significant amount of face-to-face engagement with expert individuals and
representative bodies, as well as formal public consultation. This process is
time consuming, but it leads to well-considered recommendations which can be demonstrated
to be based on the best possible evidence. The process gives the best possible
opportunity for consensus to emerge.
Independence
One of the reasons the Government asks
the Law Commission to undertake work is because we are rigorously independent.
Our recommendations are based on an evidence-based analysis of options, and our
view of the best way to reform the law. To demonstrate our independence, the
Commission always publishes its conclusions at the end of a project, laying our
final reports in Parliament. The Lord Chancellor has a duty to make an annual
statement to Parliament about the implementation of Law Commission reports.
We are, however, responsible in the
exercise of our independence. We are acutely aware of the need to put forward
realistic and workable solutions. We are often able to frame terms of reference
in a way which focuses our work within particular parameters avoiding
controversies or the opening of issues where Government policy is fixed. We
have developed Protocols with the UK and Welsh Governments which record that we
will only undertake work where Government has a “serious intention” to take
forward law reform in the area.
Staff
The Law Commission is a small
organisation of approximately 70 staff, the majority of whom are legal experts,
many specialising in a particular area of law. Each team is led by a
Commissioner and a Legal Team Manager, overseeing a number of lawyers and
Research Assistants. Our staff have policy, legislative and legal expertise,
which results in our recommendations demonstrating not just strong legal
analysis but also a deep understanding of policy development and the mechanics
of changing the law, and experience of what will work in practice. We bring in
external expert lawyers and others where necessary for particular specialist
projects where we do not already have suitable staff. We also have in-house
Parliamentary Counsel (legislative drafters) who not only draft any legislation
accompanying the project but also offer advice as to the legislative
workability of our proposals from the outset of the project. We also employ an
economist who ensures that the costs and benefits of our recommendations are
accurately and robustly assessed through the provision of accompanying Economic
Impact Assessments. There is a small Corporate Services Team, providing
communications, HR and Finance advice.
Budget
The Law Commission receives
approximately £4-5million annually from the Ministry of Justice but also seeks
to secures funding from Whitehall Departments to offset the funding from the
Ministry of Justice.